
Generating high-quality Medicare leads for agents is crucial to growing their business and connecting with the right clients. Medicare is a complex system of health benefits for seniors, requiring agents to have a deep understanding of the plans available and the ability to attract and engage potential enrollees. To succeed, Medicare agents need to focus on sourcing the best leads: individuals actively seeking assistance navigating their healthcare options.
One powerful tool in this process is leveraging specialized lead generation services like BrokerCalls™. These inbound call services target pre-qualified high-intent leads, ensuring agents spend less time prospecting and more time closing deals. BrokerCalls™ can streamline the lead generation process so agents can improve their conversion rates, expand their customer base, and provide better service to seniors needing Medicare coverage.
Ready to expand your business?
BrokerCalls™ offers highly qualified inbound calls and phone leads. Reach out and get started today.
Let’s Talk
Where Do Medicare Leads Come From?
Understanding where Medicare leads come from can be crucial for agents looking to maximize their outreach and connect with the right clients. The most common sources of Medicare leads include the following:
- Digital Marketing – The internet has become one of the most effective ways to capture Medicare leads. Through targeted digital advertising, agents can reach individuals searching for Medicare information. These ads often target keywords like “Medicare plans near me,” “Medicare Advantage,” or “Medicare enrollment,” which help attract individuals in the decision-making process.
- Search Engine Optimization (SEO) – Organic search results are key in generating Medicare leads. When an agent’s website is optimized with relevant keywords, high-quality content, and well-structured pages, it becomes more visible to individuals who search for Medicare-related information.
- Lead Generation Services (e.g., BrokerCalls™) – Specialized lead generation companies, such as BrokerCalls™, provide Medicare agents with a steady stream of high-quality, pre-qualified leads. By filtering and pre-screening these leads, BrokerCalls™ helps agents focus on warm prospects, minimizing the time spent on cold calling and improving conversion rates.
- Referrals – Referral networks are a key source of high-quality Medicare leads. Satisfied clients often refer friends, family members, or colleagues nearing retirement age or eligible for Medicare.
- Community Events – Local seminars, workshops, and community events allow Medicare agents to interact directly with potential clients. These events often target seniors or caregivers and are designed to educate them about Medicare options and enrollment periods.
- Direct Mail Campaigns – Traditional direct mail is still a common and effective way to generate Medicare leads. While less immediate than digital leads, direct mail can still be valuable for reaching a broader, often older demographic that may prefer offline communication.
By understanding these diverse lead sources and how they contribute to the lead-generation pipeline, Medicare agents can strategically tailor their marketing efforts to attract the right prospects.
Why Do Agents Push Medicare Advantage Plans?
Medicare Advantage (MA) plans, also known as Medicare Part C, are popular for agents to promote because they often provide a comprehensive, all-in-one healthcare solution for seniors and several advantages over Original Medicare. One of the main reasons agents push Medicare Advantage plans is the additional benefits they offer, which Original Medicare does not cover. These benefits may include prescription drug coverage (Part D) and dental, vision, hearing, and wellness programs bundled into a single plan. This can particularly appeal to seniors seeking a more comprehensive and affordable option.
Medicare Advantage plans generally have lower monthly premiums than traditional Medicare, making them an attractive choice for cost-conscious beneficiaries. Additionally, many Medicare Advantage plans have maximum out-of-pocket limits, providing financial protection against unexpected healthcare costs, a feature not available with Original Medicare.
Medicare Advantage plans meet a growing demand for affordable, all-inclusive healthcare coverage, which makes them appealing to agents and beneficiaries.

What’s the Difference Between a Medicare Broker and a Medicare Agent?
The terms Medicare broker and Medicare agent are often used interchangeably, but they refer to distinct roles in the insurance marketplace.
A Medicare agent works for a specific insurance company or a group of companies. They represent one or more plans from those insurers and help clients choose the best coverage option from that limited selection. Medicare agents are paid commissions by the companies they represent, and their primary responsibility is to sell the plans offered by those insurers. They may be restricted in their recommendations, as they are only authorized to discuss products from the carriers they work with.
On the other hand, a Medicare broker is independent and can work with multiple insurance companies. Brokers have the flexibility to offer a broader range of plans, including Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D options from various carriers. This allows them to compare plans across different providers to find the best fit for a client’s needs. Because brokers are not tied to a single insurance company, they can provide unbiased advice, which can be a significant advantage for clients seeking personalized guidance.
While both brokers and agents assist with Medicare enrollment, brokers offer a broader selection of plans, giving clients more options for their healthcare needs.
How Much Does a Medicare Lead Cost?
The cost of a Medicare insurance lead can differ depending on the lead generation method used, the quality of the lead, and the lead provider. On average, Medicare leads for agents can range from $20 to $100+ per lead.
Pay-per-lead services (like those offered by BrokerCalls™) charge agents for each lead generated. High-quality, pre-qualified leads (those who have expressed interest in specific Medicare plans or have been screened for eligibility) are considered higher value because they are more likely to convert into actual clients. Meanwhile, exclusive leads are sold only to one agent and tend to be more expensive than shared leads, which are sold to multiple agents. Since agents aren’t competing with others for the same prospect, exclusive leads offer a higher conversion rate.
Other factors affecting cost include the lead generation channel (digital ads, direct mail, or telemarketing), the region (some areas may have higher demand or competition), and whether the leads are targeted (e.g., focusing on a specific age group or geographic location).
While the cost of Medicare leads can vary, investing in quality, targeted leads generally offers a better return on investment for agents, as they can more effectively connect with seniors needing Medicare guidance.
Ready to expand your business?
BrokerCalls™ offers highly qualified inbound calls and phone leads. Reach out and get started today.
Let’s Talk
Partner with BrokerCalls™ for Top Medicare Leads for Agents
Partnering with BrokerCalls™ to buy primeMedicare leads is an effective way for agents to access high-quality prospects. BrokerCalls™ specializes in generating targeted inbound call leads currently seeking Medicare assistance, ensuring agents receive valuable, warm leads rather than wasting time on cold prospects.
With BrokerCalls™, agents benefit from exclusive leads, higher conversion rates, and a streamlined process that allows them to focus on selling rather than lead generation. By contacting BrokerCalls™, buying Medicare leads for agents helps them gain a competitive edge, enhancing their efficiency and success in the marketplace. Reach out today at 855-268-3773.
External Source
- Medicare.gov – Your health plan options