Generating Quality U65 Health Insurance Leads With Pay-Per-Call Campaigns
Pay-per-call lead generation can be an incredibly effective strategy if you’re an insurance agent or agency looking to grow your business in the Under 65 (U65) health insurance market. With pay-per-call campaigns, you only pay for the leads that result in an actual phone call from a prospective client. This performance-based model helps ensure you get quality leads from people actively interested in your services. However, executing a successful pay-per-call campaign for U65 insurance takes some planning and know-how. Below are some tips for making the most of this lead-generation tactic for insurance agents.
Ready to expand your business?
BrokerCalls™ offers highly qualified inbound calls and phone leads. Reach out and get started today.
Let’s Talk
Identify Your Target Audience
The first step is clearly defining your ideal U65 prospect. Are you targeting self-employed individuals, gig economy workers, or young families without employer-sponsored coverage? Understanding who you want to reach will allow you to build campaigns with messages and creative elements that resonate.
Craft an Enticing Offer
To get people to call, you need an enticing offer. You could promote a free quote comparison of plans and rates from significant providers or offer a complimentary policy review for those already covered. The key is giving people a specific, valuable reason to pick up the phone.
Optimize Your Keywords and Creative
In a pay-per-call campaign for insurance agents, your keywords, ad copy, and creative elements like images and videos need to be highly targeted and optimized. Really consider the pains, problems, and search intent of your ideal U65 prospect. Continuously test different ad variations to see what drives the most qualified call volume.
Implement Effective Call Handling
Once the calls start coming in, you need a system to handle them properly. This could mean having a team of licensed agents ready to field incoming calls during peak times or using an automated call routing system to capture lead information and schedule appointments. The last thing you want is for an excellent lead to slip through the cracks.
Score and Qualify Leads
Only some calls will be a red-hot lead ready to purchase a policy immediately. Have a process for scoring and qualifying leads based on criteria like age, income level, health status, and buyer intent. That way, you can prioritize the most promising opportunities while continuing to nurture colder leads.
Use Call Recordings and Data
One of the great advantages of a pay-per-call campaign is that you can listen to call recordings to evaluate your team’s performance and identify areas for improvement. You also get access to a wealth of data about call durations, lead sources, geographic locations, and more to refine your approach continually.
Be Prepared to Scale
If your pay-per-call efforts successfully drive a steady stream of U65 leads, you need to be ready to scale operations accordingly. This may mean bringing on additional staff, expanding your technology infrastructure, and increasing your media spending to capitalize on the momentum.
Stay Compliant
The insurance industry is highly regulated, so compliance needs to be top-of-mind for any U65 lead generation campaign. Ensure you have the proper licenses, follow all guidelines around advertising and solicitation, and implement robust data privacy and security protocols.
While an investment is required, pay-per-call can be an excellent way for insurance agents and agencies to generate exclusive U65 efficient leads. By optimizing your campaigns and having the right systems in place, you can fill your pipeline with prospects actively interested in your health insurance products and services.
Generate U65 Health Insurance Leads With BrokerCalls™
Working with a reputable pay-per-call partner like BrokerCalls™ can enhance your U65 health insurance lead generation efforts. BrokerCalls™ specializes in the insurance vertical and has extensive experience driving high-quality, exclusive phone leads for agents selling products like Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplements, and Affordable Care Act plans.
We handle every aspect of the pay-per-call process, from building optimized landing pages and ad campaigns to skilled call handling and lead transferring. BrokerCalls™ invests heavily in compliance, so you can be confident your campaigns follow all rules and regulations. With real-time reporting and access to call recordings, you gain invaluable insights to improve your strategy continuously with our flexible, pay-per-call pricing. Please call BrokerCalls™ at (855) 268-3773 or visit us on Facebook, LinkedIn, X, or Instagram for more information on generating health insurance leads for your business.
Frequently Asked Questions
We have the answers you're looking for
U65 health insurance leads are prospects under the age of 65 who are actively seeking individual or family health insurance coverage outside of employer-sponsored plans. This market includes consumers shopping during ACA open enrollment as well as those who qualify for special enrollment periods due to life changes. For insurance agents, U65 leads represent a large and growing segment of the health insurance market.
Pay-per-call campaigns generate U65 health insurance leads by running targeted digital advertising that drives interested consumers to call a tracked phone number. You only pay for calls that result in an actual conversation with a prospective client, making it a performance-based investment. This model ensures your budget is spent on consumers who have taken the initiative to pick up the phone and inquire about coverage.
Health insurance is a complex product that requires personalized guidance based on individual health needs, family situations, and financial circumstances. Consumers often prefer speaking with a knowledgeable agent rather than filling out an online form. Pay-per-call facilitates these conversations by connecting prospects with experts who can guide them to the right coverage in real time.
Pay-per-click charges advertisers for every click on their ad regardless of whether the user actually contacts the business, while pay-per-call only charges when the ad generates an actual phone call from a potential customer. This distinction means pay-per-call delivers higher-intent leads because the consumer has taken the additional step of initiating a conversation. For insurance providers, this results in a more efficient use of marketing spend.
Agents should start by defining their target demographics, including age range, geographic area, and the types of coverage they specialize in. Having a well-trained team ready to handle inbound calls promptly and professionally is essential for maximizing conversions. Working with a pay-per-call provider like BrokerCalls that offers campaign management support and real-time analytics helps agents refine their approach continuously.
Conversion rates for U65 pay-per-call leads tend to be significantly higher than those from cold calling or aged lead lists because the consumer is calling in with active purchase intent. Exact rates vary based on the agent's closing skills, the quality of the lead provider, and the specifics of the campaign targeting. Agents who respond promptly and offer clear plan comparisons typically achieve the strongest conversion performance.
BrokerCalls works with vetted publishers and employs screening processes to verify that callers meet the criteria for U65 health insurance coverage before routing them to an agent. Each lead is delivered in real time with documented consent, ensuring both quality and TCPA compliance. The company also assigns dedicated account managers who work with agents to optimize targeting and improve lead-to-sale outcomes.
U65 prospects commonly inquire about ACA-compliant marketplace plans, short-term health insurance, catastrophic coverage, and plans available through special enrollment periods. Many callers are comparing premiums, deductibles, and provider networks to find the best fit for their budget and healthcare needs. Agents who can walk prospects through multiple plan options during the initial call are better positioned to close the sale.
Yes, pay-per-call is inherently scalable because agents can increase or decrease their call volume based on team capacity and budget. As an agency grows and adds more licensed agents, it can expand its campaign to receive more calls across additional geographies and coverage types. This flexibility makes pay-per-call a practical growth engine for agencies building their U65 health insurance business.
Mobile users represent a growing share of consumers searching for health insurance, and pay-per-call is uniquely suited to capture this traffic because the call action is immediate on a mobile device. Traditional online marketing methods often lose mobile users who abandon forms on small screens. Pay-per-call eliminates this friction by letting the consumer tap to call and speak with an agent instantly.
